My school fantasies tend to revolve around characters who are quite obedient. Though certain cheekiness is not out of the question, my characters do generally back down when challenged, and don’t put up much of a fight.
This tends to be quite convenient when playing actual scenes, because I don’t know any tops for whom an out-and-out rebellion is a turn-on. It’s too easy for the spankee to disrupt the scene completely by over-bratting or over-rebelling. But that’s real-life play. How about fantasy schoolgirls? Is there room in a fantasy for a girl who is such a difficult character that she has to be manhandled over the desk to take her caning, and who doesn’t back down until, or even though, extreme pain is applied?
I can’t imagine ever being comfortable inhabiting a character like that even in a fantasy – how about you? Does rebellion ever work?
Suggest forwarding this post to Lucy Plackett and asking her opinion 😉
Well, she’s certainly naughty, but she wouldn’t fight the masters physically, which is more what I had in mind.
Shamefully, I can – tho’ of course would not regard the character as “difficult”. Fortunately my senses of self-preservation and self control mean she never gets to play now.
What I identify with is the furious energy which comes from a belief that I or others have been unfairly treated. The only time I ever received cp at school I was so angry I would happily have hit back if he hadn’t been vastly bigger than me. Instead I just went in defiance of all the rules to swing upside down from the climbing frame to show I didn’t care.
So a fantasy for me would work at least on one level if, for example, the girl has been unfairly accused and punished and fights back even if inevitably she loses on all counts.
I really, really like being manhandled. So, I could definitely inhabit such a character. However, if I were to do so, she would have to break under the punishment. I wouldn’t want to leave as rebellious as I went in.
Haron, my school fantasy’s, were always reverse. As a school boy growing up in England, I always wanted to spank my female teachers, or the headmistress. I dream’t even to this day, that I could have bent them over, raised their skirts, or dresses, waist high, pull down their knickers, or bloomers, and caned their bare bottoms with delight. Especially if they wore suspender-belt and stockings, which made their bare bottoms, even more erotic. And to top off this fantasy dream, to cane them, six or more of the very best strokes of my cane.
Haron — I find it exceedingly hard to be anything but obedient and even timid during an actual scene. Almost to the point of negating the need for a spanking at all, which is almost as bad as disrupting the scene by being too bratty! 😀 It seems, though, as I start to venture into role-playing more, that eventually, I could take on a persona more inclined to rebel than to obey.
She wouldn’t fight back physically though, as you mention — ultimately, I couldn’t imagine that level of rebellion ever working for me. In particular types of scenes with particular people, though, I could definitely see it playing out well for others.
I too am obedient, and i enjoy the idea of doing what i am told.
However, i love the idea of fysically being forced to take punishment, and i would love to experience that once. It would probably be a one-off and the Top would want to do that too.
Bratting is like swearing to me, but maybe a scene could be thought up where manhandling is actually called for.
I don’t think I would be able to be a brat, let alone over brat, during a scene. And I would never be able to actually fight the master. I would be that annoying girl that never does anything wrong.
I like the fantasy of the goody two shoes (me) in class FINALLY getting what she deserves. Maybe the other girls instigate it and maybe it wasn’t even her fault, but she’s over due for a spanking. She doesn’t down right resist, but the master has to come get her from her seat and bring her to the front of the room. The threat of being held down by one of the naughtier girls in the class is enough for her to wise up and take her caning.
nxnWhen I am playing in a group scene, especially a large shook scene, I rarely act up or rebel strongly because I don’t think group scenes are the place to do so. You need, in my opinion, to have some consideration for the other players who don’t always want to have to watch your rebellion or in fact deal with it. In a small group though, with people i trust, I tend to be much more rebellious – I am remembering a past reformatory where I attempted to run away from a master who caught me by my plait, then manhandled me over the kitchen table to thrash me whislt I struggled. It’s one of the reasons I love that weekend, I like the ‘dangerous’ element of force and compulsion
Also, when playing on my own with someone, I love to let rip, fight, force the dom to physically overpower me – and then expect him to punish me harder for my disobedience.
Damn iPhone posted my coment before I had finished -sorry.
The remainder was – the flip side to wanting to challenge is that my main partners find it hard, because my body physically
gives up – I.e my skin breaks- before my mind does. Which, out of that rebellious headspace, I would also agree is not desirable. So that kind of headspace for me is a self regualted occasional treat which is probably why I get a lot out of it – and why I am looking forward to kicking against the pricks (sorry masters!) at the reformatory so much
In a school context, as per the opening line of your post, my preference by and large is for “good girls gone bad”. They may protest, argue, try to evade punishment – as any girl would – but ultimately (in most scenes, especially school) they recognise the authority of the person who’s punishing them.
But that’s not to say that I couldn’t find it quite hot if a girl decide to fight and had to be subdued – say a couple of masters wrestling her over a desk, holding her down, whilst she was caned particularly hard.
In either case, though, the punishment has to be fair – the girl has to deserve it. If she was fighting to escape because they were dealing with her for something she hadn’t done, or otherwise unreasonably, I think I’d find the latter case (in particular) to be too abusive for my own personal comfort levels.
Great post and discussion
Great post!
Actually Haron I think Lucy if provoked would fight back, the short scene we did wasn’t enough to provoke her. I like to think she’d fight and win (but of course she wouldn’t!).
She’s prob the only one of my characters that would, the others are too submissive. But would have to play with the right people too – not all tops would appreciate a physical attack 😉
And Abel yes the thought of a couple of people sunduein
I like being (wo)man-handled, and I like rebellion, but I prefer for contests of will to be settled by non-physical means. So just as being dominated only physically would frustrate me, I wouldn’t be tempted to rebel physically, especially not in fantasy. That’s much of the attraction of a school scene for me– the strong social pressure on both the spanker and the spankee to behave in a restrained, quasi-ceremonial way.
In real life, I have been known to struggle during a particularly unpleasant spanking. Escape is just a much stronger instinct for me than putting a hand back or pleading. On rare occasions, the form of that escape involves movement of top and bottom to the floor in an ungainly heap…Generally, however, a sharp verbal reminder is more effective that purely physical restraint.
On the other hand, there is something incredibly hot about making a cheeky remark and finding oneself immediately bent over a piece of furniture for a short but intense flurry of smacks. At those times, even I find my sense of self-preservation and can respond rather submissively.